Roach R C, Larson E B, Hornbein T F, Houston C S, Bartlett S, Hardesty J, Johnson D, Perkins M
Aviat Space Environ Med. 1983 May;54(5):397-401.
A double-blind randomized study of 45 climbers on Mt. Rainier was conducted to test the effectiveness of antacids in preventing acute mountain sickness. All 45 climbed to 3353 m, and 31 continued to the summit. Ten climbers listed acute mountain sickness as the reason for not attaining the summit. Of symptoms monitored throughout the climb, neither headache, nausea, dizziness, pounding heart, nor shortness of breath differed in severity between antacid-treated and placebo-treated groups. In both groups vital capacity decreased significantly with ascent (p less than 0.05), while peak flow (p less than 0.005) and minute ventilation (p less than 0.001) increased significantly. The 7 climbers with the most severe AMS symptom scores above 4000 m had significantly lower peak flow at sea level prior to ascent compared with the other 25 climbers who completed sea level tests (p less than 0.005). The results of this study fail to document efficacy for antacid use for the prevention of acute mountain sickness.
在雷尼尔山对45名登山者进行了一项双盲随机研究,以测试抗酸剂预防急性高山病的有效性。所有45人都攀登到了3353米,其中31人继续登顶。10名登山者将急性高山病列为未登顶的原因。在整个攀登过程中监测的症状中,抗酸剂治疗组和安慰剂治疗组的头痛、恶心、头晕、心跳加速或呼吸急促的严重程度均无差异。两组的肺活量均随着海拔升高而显著下降(p<0.05),而峰值流量(p<0.005)和分钟通气量(p<0.001)则显著增加。与完成海平面测试的其他25名登山者相比,在海拔4000米以上出现最严重急性高山病症状评分的7名登山者在攀登前海平面时的峰值流量显著更低(p<0.005)。本研究结果未能证明使用抗酸剂预防急性高山病的有效性。