Wakeford R, Roberts S
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1983 Jun 4;286(6380):1796-8. doi: 10.1136/bmj.286.6380.1796.
The relation between preclinical tripos and clinical examination results and subsequent career success of 188 medical graduates of Cambridge University was measured using five indicators of success. A generally positive relation was found, but this was not specific enough to make accurate individual predictions. Present levels of appointment were more closely related to clinical than preclinical results. No support was found for the local assertion that "2.1s" do better than "firsts" in clinical medicine. Since undergraduate examination results seem to be inaccurate predictors of later performance they should not be used as the principal evidence in making selection decisions.
通过五个成功指标衡量了剑桥大学188名医学毕业生的临床前考试成绩与临床检查结果及后续职业成功之间的关系。发现了一种普遍的正相关关系,但这种关系不够具体,无法做出准确的个人预测。目前的任职水平与临床结果的相关性比与临床前结果的相关性更强。没有证据支持当地关于在临床医学中“二等一荣誉学位”比“一等荣誉学位”表现更好的说法。由于本科考试成绩似乎并不能准确预测后期表现,因此不应将其作为选拔决策的主要依据。