Stimmel B, Smith H
N Engl J Med. 1978 Aug 3;299(5):227-30. doi: 10.1056/NEJM197808032990504.
Between 1975 and 1977, 340 American citizens trained in foreign medical schools (mostly Mexican) completed a year of supervised clinical training (Fifth Pathway) in New York State before beginning residency training. Analysis of 335 such students revealed a greater tendency to remain in the State for residency training as compared to graduates of New York State medical schools (P less than 0.01). A primary-care specialty was chosen by these students significantly less often than be American graduates (P less than 0.001). Their pass rate on state licensing examinations, although higher than that of other foreign-trained medical graduates, was significantly lower than that of American-trained students (P less than 0.001). Fifth Pathway programs can provide a source of United States-citizen house officers for hospitals currently staffed mainly by alien physicians. Such programs offer foreign-trained United States physicians an opportunity to improve their clinical skills before starting residencies, but evidently do not fully overcome their educational deficits.
1975年至1977年间,340名在美国境外医学院校(大多是墨西哥的医学院校)接受培训的美国公民,在开始住院医师培训前,在纽约州完成了为期一年的临床督导培训(第五途径)。对其中335名学生的分析显示,与纽约州医学院的毕业生相比,他们留在该州接受住院医师培训的倾向更大(P小于0.01)。这些学生选择基层医疗专业的频率明显低于美国毕业生(P小于0.001)。他们在州执照考试中的通过率虽然高于其他在境外接受培训的医学毕业生,但明显低于在美国接受培训的学生(P小于0.001)。第五途径项目可为目前主要由外籍医生任职的医院提供美国公民住院医师。这类项目为在境外接受培训的美国医生提供了在开始住院医师培训前提高临床技能的机会,但显然未能完全弥补他们在教育方面的不足。