Watt P C, Patterson C C, Kennedy T L
Br Med J (Clin Res Ed). 1984 May 5;288(6427):1335-8. doi: 10.1136/bmj.288.6427.1335.
Seven hundred and thirty five patients who underwent elective vagotomy and drainage procedures in one hospital during 1957-67 were followed up until 1 September 1982. At this time 281 were dead compared with an expected 184. This gives a ratio of observed to expected deaths of 1.53 (p less than 0.0001). The most important cause of increased mortality was lung cancer, which accounted for 33 of the excess deaths (observed to expected ratio 3.53). Gastric cancer yielded an observed to expected ratio of 3.3. Other causes of death that were significantly more common than expected were cerebrovascular accident, bronchopneumonia, and colorectal cancer. It is concluded that although gastric cancer occurs more commonly after vagotomy and drainage than in the general population, it is not as important a cause of death as diseases related to smoking.
1957年至1967年间,一家医院对735例行择期迷走神经切断术和引流术的患者进行了随访,直至1982年9月1日。此时,281人死亡,而预期死亡人数为184人。观察到的死亡与预期死亡之比为1.53(p<0.0001)。死亡率增加的最重要原因是肺癌,其占额外死亡人数的33例(观察到的与预期的比率为3.53)。胃癌的观察到的与预期的比率为3.3。其他比预期明显更常见的死亡原因是脑血管意外、支气管肺炎和结直肠癌。结论是,虽然迷走神经切断术和引流术后胃癌的发生率比普通人群更高,但它并不是像与吸烟相关的疾病那样重要的死亡原因。