Contraception. 1982 Jan;25(1):1-11.
A multicentre phase III clinical trial has been undertaken to compare norethisterone enantate (NET-EN) given by two different treatment regimens and depot-medroxyprogesterone acetate (DMPA). After 18 months of observation, preliminary findings are reported for 1,589 women who received DMPA 150mg every 90 days; 790 women who received NET-EN 200mg every 60 days; and 796 women who received NET-EN, 200mg every 60 days for 6 months, then 200mg every 84 days. The overall discontinuation rates per 100 women were similar for all three treatment groups over the 18 months observation (61.8 - 63.5 per 100 women). The discontinuation rates for bleeding problems and for personal reasons were also similar for all three treatment groups. However, terminations due to amenorrhoea were significantly higher among DMPA users (12.1 and 17.4 per 100 women at 12 and 18 months) as compared with both NET-EN groups (6.8 - 8.2 per 100 women at 12 months and 10.4 - 10.9 per 100 women at 18 months). The only significant difference in pregnancy rates observed between the three groups was a higher rate at 18 months among NET-EN (84 days) users (1.6 per 100 women), as compared with DMPA users (0.2 per 100 women). There was no overall significant difference between the two NET-EN groups, although between the 6 and 18 month's follow-up when the two NET-EN regimens diverged, the NET-EN (84 days) users' pregnancy rate rose significantly, whereas in the NET-EN (60 days) group the pregnancy rate did not change. There was a significantly higher weight gain in those subjects using NET-EN at 60-day intervals compared with those using it at 84-day intervals.
一项多中心III期临床试验已开展,以比较两种不同治疗方案给予的炔诺酮庚酸酯(NET-EN)和醋酸甲羟孕酮长效注射剂(DMPA)。经过18个月的观察,报告了1589名每90天接受150mg DMPA的女性、790名每60天接受200mg NET-EN的女性以及796名每60天接受200mg NET-EN共6个月、之后每84天接受200mg NET-EN的女性的初步研究结果。在18个月的观察期内,所有三个治疗组每100名女性的总体停药率相似(每100名女性为61.8 - 63.5)。所有三个治疗组因出血问题和个人原因的停药率也相似。然而,与两个NET-EN组相比,DMPA使用者中因闭经导致的停药率显著更高(12个月和18个月时每100名女性分别为12.1和17.4)(NET-EN组12个月时每100名女性为6.8 - 8.2,18个月时为10.4 - 10.9)。在三个组之间观察到的妊娠率的唯一显著差异是,NET-EN(84天)使用者在18个月时的妊娠率较高(每100名女性为1.6),而DMPA使用者为(每100名女性为0.2)。两个NET-EN组之间总体上没有显著差异,尽管在6个月和18个月的随访期间,当两种NET-EN方案不同时,NET-EN(84天)使用者的妊娠率显著上升,而NET-EN(60天)组的妊娠率没有变化。与每84天使用一次NET-EN的受试者相比,每60天使用一次NET-EN的受试者体重增加显著更高。