Tzall W R, Sciacca R R, Blood D K, McCarthy D M, Cannon P J
Am J Cardiol. 1984 Aug 1;54(3):289-93. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(84)90185-1.
Bayes' theorem of conditional probability was applied to the diagnosis of coronary artery disease (CAD) using thallium-201 scintigraphy as the testing procedure. Thallium-201 scintiscans were evaluated with a discriminant function previously developed using the amplitude coefficients of the Fourier transforms of the scans. The technique was applied prospectively to a population of 100 patients undergoing diagnostic coronary arteriography and thallium-201 scintigraphy, including 83 patients with CAD (70% or greater stenosis of luminal diameter) and 17 control subjects. A pretest probability of CAD was determined for each patient from the patient's age, sex and anginal symptoms. The pretest probability was combined with the patient's discriminant score to determine a posttest probability for CAD. For patients with CAD, the mean posttest probability was 0.85. Moreover, 57 of 83 patients (69%) had posttest probabilities exceeding 90%, including 40 patients (48%) with posttest probabilities exceeding 99%. For control subjects, the mean posttest probability was 0.19, with 11 of 17 (65%) having a posttest probability of less than 10%. Overall, 68 subjects had a posttest probability either less than 10% or more than 90% of which 63 were correctly classified (93%). Using a 50% posttest probability as a cutoff for classification, the technique has an 89% sensitivity, an 82% specificity and an overall accuracy of 88%. Therefore, this method objectively distinguishes patients with CAD from control subjects and provides a measure of the certainty of diagnosis. In addition, the discriminant function avoids the problem of inter- and intraobserver variability in visually interpreting thallium-201 scans.
条件概率的贝叶斯定理被应用于冠状动脉疾病(CAD)的诊断,采用铊-201闪烁扫描作为检测程序。铊-201闪烁扫描通过先前使用扫描傅里叶变换的幅度系数开发的判别函数进行评估。该技术被前瞻性地应用于100名接受诊断性冠状动脉造影和铊-201闪烁扫描的患者群体,其中包括83名CAD患者(管腔直径狭窄70%或更高)和17名对照受试者。根据患者的年龄、性别和心绞痛症状为每位患者确定CAD的预测试概率。将预测试概率与患者的判别分数相结合,以确定CAD的测试后概率。对于CAD患者,测试后平均概率为0.85。此外,83名患者中有57名(69%)的测试后概率超过90%,其中40名患者(48%)的测试后概率超过99%。对于对照受试者,测试后平均概率为0.19,17名中有11名(65%)的测试后概率小于10%。总体而言,68名受试者的测试后概率要么小于10%,要么大于90%,其中63名被正确分类(93%)。使用50%的测试后概率作为分类截止值,该技术具有89%的敏感性和82%的特异性,总体准确率为88%。因此,该方法客观地将CAD患者与对照受试者区分开来,并提供了诊断确定性的度量。此外,判别函数避免了在视觉解释铊-201扫描时观察者间和观察者内变异性的问题。