Dean R H, Keyser J E, Dupont W D, Nadeau J H, Meacham P W
Ann Surg. 1984 Sep;200(3):336-44. doi: 10.1097/00000658-198409000-00011.
Assessment of the predictive value of preoperative factors in the determination of operative risk in 50 patients who underwent simultaneous aortic and renovascular procedures over a 10-year period is reported. There were six operative mortalities (12%). Factors associated with increased mortal risk were azotemia (43% vs. 7%), associated complex renal or visceral procedures (31% vs. 5%), treatment of aortic aneurysm vs. occlusive disease (17% vs. 5%), positive EKG (19% vs. 4%), age over 60 years (20% vs. 4%), and a history of diffuse peripheral vascular disease (18% vs. 7%). None of these differences, by themselves, had statistical significance. Through discriminate analysis with assignment of weighted scores to the five most powerful predictors of operative death (complex procedure--4, azotemia--4, aortic aneurysm repair--3, positive electrocardiogram--2, history of diffuse vascular disease--2), a weighted score of greater than or equal to 10 predicted operative death with an 83% sensitivity and 93% specificity (p = 0.003). Although advanced age, diabetes, severity of hypertension, and history of heart disease were associated with increased operative risk, they contributed minimal discriminate value to that provided by the preceding five variables. This was because these weaker risk factors were usually found in association with the predictors in the discriminant score. This study suggests that in patients with high weighted discriminant scores (greater than or equal to 10), consideration of operative risk is particularly important in evaluation of the proposed value of combined procedures.
报告了对50例在10年期间同时接受主动脉和肾血管手术患者术前因素预测手术风险价值的评估。有6例手术死亡(12%)。与死亡风险增加相关的因素包括氮质血症(43%对7%)、相关复杂肾脏或内脏手术(31%对5%)、主动脉瘤与闭塞性疾病的治疗(17%对5%)、心电图阳性(19%对4%)、年龄超过60岁(20%对4%)以及弥漫性外周血管疾病史(18%对7%)。这些差异单独来看均无统计学意义。通过对手术死亡的五个最有力预测因素(复杂手术——4分,氮质血症——4分,主动脉瘤修复——3分,心电图阳性——2分,弥漫性血管疾病史——2分)进行判别分析并赋予加权分数,加权分数大于或等于10分预测手术死亡的敏感度为83%,特异度为93%(p = 0.003)。尽管高龄、糖尿病、高血压严重程度以及心脏病史与手术风险增加相关,但它们对上述五个变量所提供的判别价值贡献极小。这是因为这些较弱的风险因素通常与判别分数中的预测因素同时出现。本研究表明,对于加权判别分数高(大于或等于10分)的患者,在评估联合手术的预期价值时,考虑手术风险尤为重要。