Watt P C, Spence R A, Campbell R C, McGurk J J, Whytes D G
Postgrad Med J. 1984 Aug;60(706):518-22. doi: 10.1136/pgmj.60.706.518.
Since many dyspeptic patients are still investigated initially by radiology, a policy was initiated whereby all such patients were directly referred for combined simultaneous double-contrast barium meal and cholecystogram. This policy was aimed at reducing patient visits to hospital and increasing diagnostic yield. The results of 1,444 combined procedures are presented. Of these, 310 (25.5%) had a positive finding on barium meal only; 275 (19%) were positive for cholecystogram only; 117 (8.1%) were positive for both examinations; 742 (51.4%) were negative for both examinations. Of all the patients (427) who had a positive finding on barium meal, 27.4% (117) also had a positive finding on cholecystogram. Of all the patients (392) with a positive cholecystogram, 29.8% (117) also had a positive barium meal. Diagnostic yield rose considerably with patient age. It was found that simultaneous barium meal and cholecystogram presented no serious technical difficulties. It was concluded that in patients over 40 years old, this policy improved diagnostic yield as many patients had both gall bladder and upper gastrointestinal pathology. In all other patients this policy markedly reduced the number of hospital visits. Combined simultaneous double-contrast barium meal and cholecystogram is therefore recommended for hospitals which used radiology for the first line investigation of dyspepsia. Also, the general principle of examination of both gall bladder and upper gastrointestinal tract is pertinent where other first line investigations are used.
由于许多消化不良患者最初仍接受放射学检查,因此启动了一项政策,即所有此类患者都直接转诊进行同时双对比钡餐和胆囊造影联合检查。该政策旨在减少患者的医院就诊次数并提高诊断率。本文展示了1444例联合检查的结果。其中,310例(25.5%)仅钡餐检查结果为阳性;275例(19%)仅胆囊造影检查结果为阳性;117例(8.1%)两项检查结果均为阳性;742例(51.4%)两项检查结果均为阴性。在所有钡餐检查结果为阳性的患者(427例)中,27.4%(117例)的胆囊造影检查结果也为阳性。在所有胆囊造影检查结果为阳性的患者(392例)中,29.8%(117例)的钡餐检查结果也为阳性。诊断率随患者年龄显著上升。结果发现,同时进行钡餐和胆囊造影检查不存在严重的技术困难。得出的结论是,对于40岁以上的患者,该政策提高了诊断率,因为许多患者同时患有胆囊和上消化道疾病。对于所有其他患者,该政策显著减少了医院就诊次数。因此,对于将放射学作为消化不良一线检查手段的医院,建议采用同时双对比钡餐和胆囊造影联合检查。此外,在使用其他一线检查手段时,对胆囊和上消化道进行检查的一般原则也是适用的。