Miller L B, Bizzell R P
Child Dev. 1984 Aug;55(4):1570-87.
Follow-up of achievement test and IQ data on low-income black youths who had participated for 1 year in Bereiter-Engelmann, DARCEE, Montessori, or Traditional prekindergarten was continued through ninth and tenth grades. Stable trends persisted. Montessori males and DARCEE females were high; Montessori males were performing at about grade level on reading and math; IQs parallelled achievement test results. Additional tests of fluid intelligence, task persistence, self-esteem, divergent thinking, task approach, and aspirations and expectations were administered in ninth and tenth grades. Results from program comparisons and factor analyses were consistent with those on IQ and school achievement. The possibility of relationships between techniques used in the different preschool programs and sex differences in children's developmental level was discussed.
对参加了1年贝雷特-恩格尔曼、达西、蒙台梭利或传统学前班的低收入黑人青少年的成绩测试和智商数据进行了跟踪,一直持续到九年级和十年级。稳定的趋势依然存在。蒙台梭利班的男生和达西班的女生成绩较高;蒙台梭利班的男生在阅读和数学方面的表现约为年级水平;智商与成绩测试结果平行。在九年级和十年级还进行了流体智力、任务坚持性、自尊、发散性思维、任务方法以及抱负和期望等方面的额外测试。项目比较和因素分析的结果与智商和学业成绩的结果一致。讨论了不同学前教育项目所采用的技术与儿童发展水平性别差异之间存在关联的可能性。