Butzelaar R M, van Dongen J A, de Graaf P W, van der Schoot J B
Eur J Cancer Clin Oncol. 1984 Jul;20(7):877-80. doi: 10.1016/0277-5379(84)90158-5.
A 5-yr follow-up study was performed in 90 patients with stage I and II breast cancer who had a routine preoperative bone scan. The percentage of positive preoperative scans was 3.4%. Twenty-four of the 90 patients died within 5 yr. In all patients except five a follow-up scan was obtained. The results of our first study were confirmed. In only one of the three patients with a positive preoperative scan suspicious for bone metastases did bone metastases develop in this 5-yr follow-up study. One patient with an equivocal preoperative scan developed bone metastases. In 14 of the 16 patients with bone metastases and a positive scan in the follow-up period the preoperative scan was negative. From the preoperative and follow-up scan results we conclude that in stage I and II breast cancer there is no value in preoperative bone scanning. Routine bone scanning in the follow-up period appears to have little value in the asymptomatic patient.
对90例I期和II期乳腺癌患者进行了一项为期5年的随访研究,这些患者术前均进行了常规骨扫描。术前扫描阳性率为3.4%。90例患者中有24例在5年内死亡。除5例患者外,所有患者均进行了随访扫描。我们第一项研究的结果得到了证实。在术前扫描阳性且怀疑有骨转移的3例患者中,只有1例在这项5年随访研究中发生了骨转移。1例术前扫描结果不明确的患者发生了骨转移。在随访期间有骨转移且扫描阳性的16例患者中,有14例术前扫描为阴性。根据术前和随访扫描结果,我们得出结论,对于I期和II期乳腺癌患者,术前骨扫描没有价值。在随访期间对无症状患者进行常规骨扫描似乎也没有什么价值。