Handler C E, Sowton E
Br Heart J. 1984 Sep;52(3):299-303. doi: 10.1136/hrt.52.3.299.
Diurnal variation and reproducibility of abnormalities occurring during predischarge postinfarction treadmill exercise testing were investigated in 41 patients. Each patient was exercised using a limited Naughton protocol before 0800 and after 1800 h on two consecutive days. No complications arose. Individual ischaemic abnormalities were poorly reproducible in any patient. No abnormality and no patient showed significant diurnal variation. When the presence of any one of three ischaemic abnormalities (ST segment depression or elevation and angina) was analysed the reproducibility of an ischaemic result in the two morning and the two evening tests was 72% and 95% respectively with no significant difference between the two. The reproducibility of an ischaemic result in all four tests was 66%. The reproducibility of the test for either the presence or absence of an ischaemic result was 71%. No training effect could be shown either for the group as a whole or for any individual patient. There were no appreciable differences in either the heart rates or systolic blood pressures during exercise among those patients with non-reproducible ischaemic test results. Thus it is concluded that an assessment of any one of three ischaemic abnormalities improves the reproducibility of the result of submaximal exercise testing after infarction. Mechanisms other than increased myocardial oxygen consumption related to increased heart rate and systolic blood pressure at submaximal exercise tolerance are needed to explain non-reproducible ischaemic test results.
对41例患者出院前心肌梗死后平板运动试验期间出现的异常情况的日变化和可重复性进行了研究。每位患者在连续两天的上午8点前和下午6点后使用有限的诺顿方案进行运动。未出现并发症。任何患者的个体缺血异常情况重复性都很差。没有异常情况,也没有患者表现出明显的日变化。当分析三种缺血异常情况(ST段压低或抬高以及心绞痛)中任何一种情况的存在时,上午两次和下午两次试验中缺血结果的可重复性分别为72%和95%,两者之间无显著差异。四次试验中缺血结果的可重复性为66%。试验结果为有或无缺血结果的可重复性为71%。无论是对整个组还是对任何个体患者,均未显示出训练效果。在缺血试验结果不可重复的患者中,运动期间的心率或收缩压没有明显差异。因此得出结论,对三种缺血异常情况中的任何一种进行评估可提高梗死后次极量运动试验结果的可重复性。需要用除次极量运动耐量时与心率和收缩压增加相关的心肌耗氧量增加之外的其他机制来解释缺血试验结果不可重复的情况。