Koskenvuo M, Langinvainio H, Kaprio J, Lönnqvist J, Tienari P
Acta Genet Med Gemellol (Roma). 1984;33(2):321-32. doi: 10.1017/s0001566000007364.
Hospitalization rates of monozygotic (MZ) and dizygotic (DZ) twin pairs in Finland were compared for schizophrenia, neuroses, and alcoholism. Record-linkage of hospital records and death certificates for the years 1972-1979 was carried out for persons in the Finnish Twin Cohort (16,649 like-sexed twin pairs). The ratio of the number of observed vs that of expected concordant pairs and the ratio of concordance rates between MZ and DZ pairs were greater among males than females, and greater among young (40 years old or less) than among older pairs. The highest difference was found in schizophrenia and the lowest in neuroses. Pairwise concordance rates for schizophrenia (11.0% for MZ and 1.8% for DZ) seem to indicate great environmental influence (high proportion of discordant pairs) with apparent genetic liability (6.1-fold ratio in concordance between MZ and DZ pairs). In neurotic disorders, the difference of pairwise concordance rates between MZ and DZ pairs (6.8% vs 4.0%) was quite low, not strongly supporting a genetic hypothesis. Of the MZ pairs concordant for psychiatric hospitalization, 47% had lived together for their whole life time; of those discordant, 16% lived together. The corresponding figures for DZ pairs were 18% and 15%. The effect of intrapair relationships in disease-concordant pairs should be taken into account when evaluating the effect of genetic and environmental factors in psychiatric disorders.
对芬兰单卵(MZ)和双卵(DZ)双胞胎患精神分裂症、神经症和酗酒的住院率进行了比较。对芬兰双胞胎队列(16,649对同性双胞胎)中1972 - 1979年的医院记录和死亡证明进行了记录链接。观察到的与预期一致对的数量之比以及MZ和DZ对之间的一致率之比在男性中高于女性,在年轻(40岁及以下)双胞胎对中高于年长双胞胎对。在精神分裂症中差异最大,在神经症中差异最小。精神分裂症的成对一致率(MZ为11.0%,DZ为1.8%)似乎表明环境影响很大(不一致对的比例很高),同时存在明显的遗传易感性(MZ和DZ对之间的一致率为6.1倍)。在神经症中,MZ和DZ对之间的成对一致率差异(6.8%对4.0%)相当低,不太支持遗传假说。在因精神疾病住院而一致的MZ对中,47%一生都生活在一起;在不一致的对中,16%生活在一起。DZ对的相应数字分别为18%和15%。在评估遗传和环境因素对精神疾病的影响时,应考虑成对关系对疾病一致对的影响。