Cawte J, Tarrant M
Aust N Z J Psychiatry. 1984 Dec;18(4):388-90. doi: 10.3109/00048678409158802.
A case of so-called Capgras' syndrome occurring in an elderly woman showing several degenerative conditions is presented as a basis for questioning the value of preserving this diagnostic term. It is pointed out that the concept of the changeling has ancient provenance in man's thought down the ages, and that its occurrence in psychosis does not justify its ascription as a syndrome. 'Changeling' or 'imposture' are terms which describe this kind of delusion usually occurring in underlying schizophrenic, affective and organic syndromes.
本文报告了一例发生在患有多种退行性疾病的老年女性身上的所谓卡普格拉综合征,以此质疑保留这一诊断术语的价值。文中指出,“易人错觉”这一概念在人类思想中由来已久,而它在精神病中的出现并不能证明将其归为一种综合征是合理的。“易人错觉”或“冒名顶替妄想”是描述这种通常发生在潜在精神分裂症、情感障碍和器质性综合征中的妄想的术语。