Tarr R R, Garfinkel A I, Sarmiento A
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1984 Jan;66(1):65-70.
In intact fresh cadaver specimens, we experimentally studied angular and rotatory deformities at the distal and middle levels of the forearm. The remaining pronation and supination motions were measured. When both bones of the forearm were angulated with a combined deformity (radio-ulnar or dorsovolar, or both) of 10 degrees, a loss of pronation-supination of 12.5 +/- 4.5 per cent occurred in the forearms with a distal-third fracture; in the forearms with a middle-third fracture the average loss was 16.0 +/- 5.7 per cent. Pronation losses were similar for both distal and middle-third deformities. However, supination losses were much less affected (p less than 0.01) in forearms with deformities at the distal-third level while the losses were considered drastic for middle-third deformities. Rotatory deformities produced losses of pronation-supination that were equal to the degree of deformity.
Study of the artificially created deformities in cadavera indicated that angular and rotatory deformities of the forearm of 10 degrees or less result in minimum limitation of pronation-supination. These degrees of limitation of motion in clinical practice are easily compensated for and are cosmetically acceptable. The fact that the perfect anatomical restoration of fracture alignment that often is obtained with internal fixation does not always result in complete restoration of motion suggests that: (1) this residual impairment of function is due to soft-tissue scarring, and (2) the mild angular and rotatory deformities resulting from nonsurgical treatment of fractures of the forearm may produce limitations of motion of an equally acceptable degree.(ABSTRACT TRUNCATED AT 250 WORDS)
在完整的新鲜尸体标本中,我们对前臂远端和中段的成角及旋转畸形进行了实验研究。测量了剩余的旋前和旋后运动。当双前臂骨成角合并10度(桡尺或掌背,或两者皆有)的复合畸形时,远端三分之一骨折的前臂旋前 - 旋后功能丧失12.5±4.5%;中段三分之一骨折的前臂平均丧失16.0±5.7%。远端和中段三分之一畸形的旋前丧失相似。然而,远端三分之一水平有畸形的前臂旋后丧失受影响较小(p<0.01),而中段三分之一畸形的旋后丧失则较为严重。旋转畸形导致的旋前 - 旋后丧失程度与畸形程度相等。
对尸体中人为制造的畸形的研究表明,10度或更小的前臂成角和旋转畸形导致旋前 - 旋后功能受限最小。临床实践中这些运动受限程度易于代偿且在外观上可接受。通过内固定常能实现骨折对线的完美解剖复位,但并不总能完全恢复运动功能,这一事实表明:(1)这种功能的残余损害是由于软组织瘢痕形成;(2)前臂骨折非手术治疗导致的轻度成角和旋转畸形可能产生同样可接受程度的运动受限。(摘要截断于250字)