Walker E, McGuire M, Bettes B
Br J Clin Psychol. 1984 Feb;23 ( Pt 1):37-44. doi: 10.1111/j.2044-8260.1984.tb00624.x.
Schizophrenics have been shown to manifest a significant deficit in identifying facial expressions of emotion. The present study sought to determine whether this deficit lay at the level of decoding facial cues of emotion, or whether it is specific to the process of labelling emotional faces. The latter specific deficit would be consistent with the hypothesis of left-hemisphere dysfunction in schizophrenia. Samples of schizophrenics, patients with affective disorders and normal controls were tested on a battery of facial tasks that had previously been shown to be capable of distinguishing between patients with left- and right-hemisphere lesions. The battery was comprised of four tests: facial discrimination, emotion discrimination, emotion labelling, and a multiple choice emotion task. The performance of affective patients fell midway between that of schizophrenics and normals on all the tasks. Schizophrenics performed significantly below normals on all but the facial discrimination task, and below affective patients on the emotion labelling task. There were no other significant group differences in performance. The performance pattern manifested by schizophrenics across the four tasks is not comparable to that shown by patients with unilateral brain damage. These results indicate that previously reported emotion identification deficits in schizophrenia were not solely a function of the labelling requirements of the tasks. Instead it appears that schizophrenics, although capable of deciphering facial cues of identity, are impaired in the ability to extract salient emotional cues from faces.
研究表明,精神分裂症患者在识别面部表情方面存在显著缺陷。本研究旨在确定这种缺陷是在于对面部情感线索的解码层面,还是特定于给情感面孔贴标签的过程。后一种特定缺陷将与精神分裂症患者左半球功能障碍的假设相一致。对精神分裂症患者样本、情感障碍患者样本和正常对照组进行了一系列面部任务测试,这些任务先前已被证明能够区分左半球和右半球病变的患者。该测试组包括四项测试:面部辨别、情感辨别、情感标签和多项选择情感任务。在所有任务中,情感障碍患者的表现介于精神分裂症患者和正常人之间。除面部辨别任务外,精神分裂症患者在所有任务中的表现均显著低于正常人,在情感标签任务中的表现低于情感障碍患者。在表现上没有其他显著的组间差异。精神分裂症患者在这四项任务中的表现模式与单侧脑损伤患者的表现模式不可比。这些结果表明,先前报道的精神分裂症患者的情感识别缺陷不仅仅是任务标签要求的作用。相反,似乎精神分裂症患者虽然能够解读面部身份线索,但在从面部提取显著情感线索的能力方面存在缺陷。