Reed D, McGee D, Yano K
Am J Epidemiol. 1984 Mar;119(3):356-70. doi: 10.1093/oxfordjournals.aje.a113754.
The concept of general susceptibility to disease has developed as a unifying explanation for the findings that a variety of diseases are associated with certain social and cultural situations. This hypothesis was tested in a prospective study of 4251 men of Japanese ancestry in Hawaii who answered a psychosocial questionnaire in 1971. The seven-year incidence rates of coronary heart disease, stroke, cancer, and all deaths during the period December 1971-January 1979 were analyzed for association with individual questions and five summary scores measuring geographic and generational mobility, sociocultural and spousal inconsistency, and social networks. Among all questions and summary scores measuring mobility and inconsistency, there was only one statistically significant association with any disease, and this association was in the opposite direction to that predicted by the hypothesis. The measures of social networks were not associated with either the incidence of stroke, cancer, or all diseases combined, but were associated with coronary heart disease, as reported in detail earlier. The authors examined the joint interaction of the postulated stressful processes of mobility and inconsistency with the protective effects of social networks, with special attention to the men in the highest levels of mobility and inconsistency. They found no significant associations, and thus there was no support for the hypothesis that social networks are especially protective among persons in the highest levels of mobility and inconsistency. The inclusion of known health hazards, cigarette smoking, and high systolic blood pressure levels did not alter these findings.
疾病易感性这一概念的发展,是为了解释各种疾病与特定社会和文化状况相关这一发现而提出的统一解释。该假设在一项对夏威夷4251名日裔男性的前瞻性研究中得到检验,这些男性在1971年回答了一份社会心理调查问卷。分析了1971年12月至1979年1月期间冠心病、中风、癌症的七年发病率以及所有死亡情况,以确定其与各个问题以及五个综合得分之间的关联,这五个综合得分衡量的是地理和代际流动性、社会文化和配偶不一致性以及社会网络。在所有衡量流动性和不一致性的问题及综合得分中,与任何疾病仅有一个具有统计学意义的关联,且此关联与该假设所预测的方向相反。社会网络的衡量指标与中风、癌症或所有疾病的综合发病率均无关联,但与冠心病有关,这一点在之前已有详细报道。作者研究了假设的流动性和不一致性应激过程与社会网络保护作用的联合交互作用,特别关注了流动性和不一致性处于最高水平的男性。他们未发现显著关联,因此,社会网络在流动性和不一致性处于最高水平的人群中具有特别保护作用这一假设未得到支持。纳入已知的健康危险因素、吸烟和高收缩压水平并未改变这些发现。