Gross N J, Skorodin M S
N Engl J Med. 1984 Aug 16;311(7):421-5. doi: 10.1056/NEJM198408163110701.
To study the relative contributions of parasympathetic and sympathetic mechanisms in airway obstruction in patients with emphysema, we gave supramaximal doses of anticholinergic and adrenergic agents in sequence and in combination. Serial doses of one agent were administered to achieve a plateau of bronchodilatation; after that the other agent was administered. The plateau achieved with the anticholinergic agent (atropine methonitrate) was significantly higher than that achieved with the adrenergic agent (salbutamol). When the adrenergic agent was given first, additional bronchodilatation was achieved with subsequent use of the anticholinergic agent. When the anticholinergic agent was given first, no additional bronchodilatation was achieved with subsequent administration of the adrenergic agent. When both agents were given simultaneously, the degree of bronchodilatation was virtually identical to that obtained with the anticholinergic agent alone. Tests sensitive to small-airway and large-airway function and lung volumes gave essentially the same results. Thus, all achievable bronchodilatation was obtained with the anticholinergic agent alone. These results suggest that the two classes of agents produce bronchodilatation through a common cholinergic pathway in emphysema, and support the concept that parasympathetic activity is the dominant reversible component of airway obstruction in this disease.
为研究副交感神经和交感神经机制在肺气肿患者气道阻塞中的相对作用,我们先后序贯及联合给予了超最大剂量的抗胆碱能药物和肾上腺素能药物。给予一种药物的系列剂量以达到支气管扩张的平台期;之后再给予另一种药物。抗胆碱能药物(硝酸甲基阿托品)所达到的平台期显著高于肾上腺素能药物(沙丁胺醇)所达到的平台期。当先给予肾上腺素能药物时,随后使用抗胆碱能药物可实现额外的支气管扩张。当先给予抗胆碱能药物时,随后给予肾上腺素能药物则未实现额外的支气管扩张。当同时给予两种药物时,支气管扩张程度实际上与单独使用抗胆碱能药物时相同。对小气道和大气道功能及肺容量敏感的检测得出了基本相同的结果。因此,单独使用抗胆碱能药物即可实现所有可达到的支气管扩张。这些结果表明,在肺气肿中,这两类药物通过共同的胆碱能途径产生支气管扩张,并支持了副交感神经活动是该疾病气道阻塞中主要的可逆性成分这一概念。