Hillas J, Booth R J, Somerfield S, Morton R, Avery J, Wilson J D
Clin Allergy. 1980 May;10(3):253-8. doi: 10.1111/j.1365-2222.1980.tb02104.x.
A double-blind crossover study has compared intra-nasal sodium cromoglycate (SCG) with beclomethasone dipropionate (BDP), and both drugs with placebo, in fifty-two chronic perennial rhinitis patients. BDP was significantly more effective in relieving symptoms than SCG (76.9% and 50% of the patients improved respectively, P < 0.01). Both drugs were more active than placebos but while BDP was very clearly more effective (P < 0.0005) SCG was only marginally better than its placebo (P < 0.05, Fisher; P = 0.068, chi 2). BDP was selected by 56% of the patients as the best agent for continuing therapy at the end of the trial. By contrast SCG was preferred by the same number of patients as chose the two placebos (11.5%).
一项双盲交叉研究对52例慢性常年性鼻炎患者使用鼻内色甘酸钠(SCG)与二丙酸倍氯米松(BDP)进行了比较,并将这两种药物与安慰剂进行了对照。BDP在缓解症状方面明显比SCG更有效(分别有76.9%和50%的患者症状改善,P<0.01)。两种药物都比安慰剂更有效,但BDP的效果非常明显更好(P<0.0005),而SCG仅略优于其安慰剂(P<0.05,费舍尔检验;P = 0.068,卡方检验)。在试验结束时,56%的患者选择BDP作为继续治疗的最佳药物。相比之下,选择SCG的患者数量与选择两种安慰剂的患者数量相同(11.5%)。