Berman J L, Wynne J, Cohn P F
Circulation. 1978 Sep;58(3 Pt 1):505-12. doi: 10.1161/01.cir.58.3.505.
To determine the value of a multivariate approach for the analysis of the treadmill exercise tolerance test (ETT), 237 patients referred for evaluation of chest pain who underwent a standard Bruce protocol ETT and coronary arteriography were studied. Predictive value of a positive ETT was 0.78 (43/55) using 1.0--1.9 mm ST segment depression criterion, 0.97 (59/61) using greater than or equal to 2.0 mm ST segment depression. When the 1.0--1.9 mm ST criterion was combined with peak systolic blood pressure-heart rate product (double product) less than or smaller than 23,000, exercise duration less than 6 minutes, and ST depression for greater than 3 minutes into recovery, predictive value improved to 0.89 in 18 patients with any two of the above. Predictive value for multivessel disease was also improved using non-ST criteria. Predictive value of a negative ETT for absence of coronary artery disease was 0.60 (29/48), and was 0.86 (12/14) if double product was greater than or equal to 30,000. Presence of chest pain during ETT did not improve predictive value of any type of test. Digitalis ingestion in 33 patients was not associated with decreased predictive value of a positive test. These data suggest that the predictive value of both positive and negative ETT in a symptomatic population can be improved with a multivariate approach.
为了确定多变量方法在分析平板运动耐量试验(ETT)中的价值,我们研究了237例因胸痛接受评估且进行了标准布鲁斯方案ETT和冠状动脉造影的患者。使用1.0 - 1.9毫米ST段压低标准时,ETT阳性的预测值为0.78(43/55),使用大于或等于2.0毫米ST段压低标准时,预测值为0.97(59/61)。当将1.0 - 1.9毫米ST标准与收缩压峰值 - 心率乘积(双乘积)小于23,000、运动持续时间小于6分钟以及恢复阶段ST段压低超过3分钟相结合时,上述任意两项符合的18例患者的预测值提高到了0.89。使用非ST标准时,多支血管病变的预测值也有所提高。ETT阴性对无冠状动脉疾病的预测值为0.60(29/48),如果双乘积大于或等于30,000,则预测值为0.86(12/14)。ETT期间胸痛的出现并未提高任何类型检测的预测值。33例患者服用洋地黄与阳性检测的预测值降低无关。这些数据表明,采用多变量方法可以提高有症状人群中ETT阳性和阴性结果的预测值。