Altshuler H L
Curr Alcohol. 1981;8:343-57.
Many animal models have been used for alcoholism research. No single model is suitable for all types of research about alcohol, its actions and abuse. This article surveys the varieties of models that have been used and categorizes them into classes called "chronic", "reinforcement" and "genetic" models and discusses the strengths, weaknesses and applications of each group. The diversity and scope of alcoholism offers unique challenges to the conduct of laboratory research with experimental animals. Animal models (AM) of the disease would have to encompass a broad range of variables No single model can incorporate all aspects of the disorder nor fulfill the needs of all research projects. Consequently, many different AM have been proposed. This review classifies those models, describes their underlying premises, experimental applications and their relative strengths and limitations. The scientific literature contains numerous examples of essentially sound experiments that lack credibility because of weaknesses in design aspects associated with the selection or use of AM. The alcoholism literature cannot be excluded from that statement. There are many examples of the inappropriate use of AM in alcoholism research and of poorly conceived attempts to use models developed for specific experimental applications in experiments requiring an entirely different approach. Furthermore, a persistent problem that is unique to alcoholism research relates to providing appropriate controls. Since alcohol (ALC) has caloric as well as pharmacological effects, dual controls must be established. The caloric effects of ALC can alter an animal's nutritional state in important ways. Therefore, studies involving more than one or two ALC doses must provide adequate controls for both the pharmacological and the non-specific nutritive effects. Unfortunately, such controls are often difficult to establish and validate.
许多动物模型已被用于酒精中毒研究。没有单一的模型适用于所有关于酒精、其作用及滥用的研究类型。本文综述了已使用的各类模型,并将它们分为“慢性”“强化”和“遗传”模型三类,同时讨论了每组模型的优缺点及应用。酒精中毒的多样性和范围给用实验动物进行实验室研究带来了独特的挑战。该疾病的动物模型必须涵盖广泛的变量。没有单一的模型能够囊括该病症的所有方面,也无法满足所有研究项目的需求。因此,人们提出了许多不同的动物模型。本综述对这些模型进行了分类,描述了它们的基本前提、实验应用以及相对优势和局限性。科学文献中有大量实例表明,一些实验在本质上是合理的,但由于与动物模型的选择或使用相关的设计方面存在缺陷,导致缺乏可信度。酒精中毒文献也不例外。在酒精中毒研究中,存在许多不恰当使用动物模型的例子,以及一些构思欠佳的尝试,即在需要完全不同方法的实验中使用为特定实验应用而开发的模型。此外,酒精中毒研究特有的一个长期问题与提供适当的对照有关。由于酒精既有热量效应又有药理作用,必须建立双重对照。酒精的热量效应会以重要方式改变动物的营养状态。因此,涉及超过一两种酒精剂量的研究必须为药理效应和非特异性营养效应都提供充分的对照。不幸的是,这样的对照往往难以建立和验证。