Osborn J W
Am J Phys Anthropol. 1982 Mar;57(3):273-81. doi: 10.1002/ajpa.1330570305.
A helicoidal plane of postcanine occlusion has been patchily reported in many recent and fossil dentitions of man, and has been suggested as a taxonomic marker distinguishing between the dentitions of Homo and Australopithecines. The present paper describes the helicoidal plane in 19 out of 23 modern human (probably Indian) worn dentitions, in both gracile and robust Australopithecines and in extant anthropoids. It is suggested that tooth wear converts the plane of occlusion present in little-worn teeth, the Monson curve, into a helicoidal plane when 1) the diet is more abrasive, 2) the enamel is thinner and less abrasion resistant, and 3) a longer time separates the eruption of the three molar teeth in a jaw quadrant. A model demonstrates that during the power stroke of a chewing cycle the working side molars move in much the same direction whether the molar occlusal plan follows a Monson curve or a helicoidal plane. The difference is that in the former case the three molars work at the same time while in the latter case they work in sequence from anterior to posterior, thereby concentrating force on one tooth at a time. Because the occlusal plane changes during the life of individuals consuming an abrasive diet, the condition of most anthropoids and hominids, it is argued that the Monson curve has functional significance not because of its influence on occlusal relations and/or jaw movement but because the molar teeth are embedded in bone roughly perpendicular to it, a direction which resists tilting of the teeth during mastication. It is concluded that the helicoidal plane probably has little if any value as a taxonomic marker.
在最近许多现代人以及化石人类的牙列中,间断地报道过一种犬齿后咬合螺旋面,有人提出它可作为区分智人和南方古猿牙列的分类学标志。本文描述了23例现代人类(可能是印度人)磨损牙列中的19例、纤细型和粗壮型南方古猿以及现存类人猿的螺旋面。研究表明,当出现以下情况时,牙齿磨损会将磨损较少的牙齿所具有的咬合平面(孟森曲线)转变为螺旋面:1)饮食的磨损性更强;2)牙釉质更薄且耐磨性更低;3)下颌象限内三颗磨牙萌出的时间间隔更长。一个模型显示,在咀嚼周期的动力冲程中,无论磨牙咬合平面遵循孟森曲线还是螺旋面,工作侧磨牙的运动方向大致相同。不同之处在于,在前一种情况下,三颗磨牙同时工作,而在后一种情况下,它们从前向后依次工作,从而每次将力集中在一颗牙齿上。由于在食用磨损性食物的个体一生中咬合平面会发生变化,而大多数类人猿和原始人类都属于这种情况,因此有人认为孟森曲线具有功能意义,并非因为它对咬合关系和/或颌骨运动有影响,而是因为磨牙大致垂直于该曲线嵌入骨中,这个方向能在咀嚼过程中抵抗牙齿的倾斜。研究得出的结论是,螺旋面作为分类学标志可能几乎没有价值。