Christou N V, Pietsch J B, Meakins J L
Can J Surg. 1983 Mar;26(2):139-42.
To determine whether repeated skin tests can augment a previously weak delayed hypersensitivity response or convert previously nonreacting tests and thus yield false-positive data, the authors carried out retrospective analysis of 426 skin tests on 107 patients who had a mean of 4.3 weekly tests with five recall antigens. They also skin tested 10 healthy volunteers weekly for up to 6 weeks. Reactions (induration measured in millimetres) were recorded and a regression and correlation analysis was carried out. Analysis of variance was used to compare reaction means of volunteers for each recall antigen at each time interval. All volunteers were reactive to two or more antigens. In the volunteer group there was no augmentation of initially reactive antigen responses except for Varidase and only after 5 weeks. Of 16 initially negative responses to some antigens in this same group, only 3 were converted to reactions of more than 5 mm, all responses being to purified protein derivative. No conversion occurred in the hospitalized patients. There was no significant correlation between repeated skin tests and the delayed hypersensitivity response to the antigens except for Candida in the retrospective patient group, up to 160 days from the original skin test. The data indicate that there is no augmentation of the delayed hypersensitivity response or conversion of initial nonreacting skin tests with any of the antigens tested except Candida.
为了确定重复皮肤试验是否能增强先前较弱的迟发型超敏反应,或者使先前无反应的试验转为阳性从而产生假阳性数据,作者对107例患者的426次皮肤试验进行了回顾性分析,这些患者平均每周进行4.3次试验,使用五种回忆抗原。他们还对10名健康志愿者每周进行皮肤试验,持续6周。记录反应(硬结以毫米为单位测量)并进行回归和相关性分析。采用方差分析比较每个时间间隔内志愿者对每种回忆抗原的反应平均值。所有志愿者对两种或更多种抗原呈反应性。在志愿者组中,除了Varidase且仅在5周后,最初有反应的抗原反应没有增强。在该组中,对某些抗原最初16次阴性反应中,只有3次转为超过5毫米的反应,所有反应均针对纯化蛋白衍生物。住院患者中未发生转化。在回顾性患者组中,除了念珠菌外,在距初次皮肤试验长达160天的时间里,重复皮肤试验与对抗原的迟发型超敏反应之间没有显著相关性。数据表明,除了念珠菌外,使用所测试的任何抗原进行重复皮肤试验均不会增强迟发型超敏反应,也不会使最初无反应的皮肤试验发生转化。