Tress B M
Radiology. 1983 Jan;146(1):87-9. doi: 10.1148/radiology.146.1.6849072.
One thousand patients had both CT of the head and a conventional skull series of radiographs. Radiographic findings were abnormal in 250 patients (25%), but only 64 patients (6.4%) had diagnostically significant abnormalities at radiography that were not detected by CT. If the 163 patients who presented after acute trauma were excluded from the series, only 39 (4.7%) of the remaining patients had radiographically significant abnormal findings that were not seen at CT, and only two (0.2%) of these abnormalities could not be diagnosed by a lateral skull radiograph alone. In only five patients (0.5%) was the management actively changed because an abnormality that was detected at skull radiography was not detected at CT. Thus, in nontrauma patients who have stroke, epilepsy, dementia, or nonspecific symptoms without focal signs, or have recently undergone craniotomy, and who have been referred for CT, skull radiographs are not justified. In the patient with a history and findings that are strongly suggestive of a pathological disorder anywhere other than in the sella turcica, cerebello-pontine angle, and paranasal sinuses, only the lateral skull radiograph should be obtained after CT, and only if CT is equivocal.
1000例患者均接受了头部CT检查和传统的颅骨系列X线片检查。X线片检查结果异常的患者有250例(25%),但只有64例(6.4%)患者的X线片检查发现了有诊断意义的异常,而CT检查未检测到这些异常。如果将163例急性创伤后就诊的患者排除在该系列之外,其余患者中只有39例(4.7%)有X线片检查发现的有显著意义的异常,而CT检查未发现这些异常,且其中只有2例(0.2%)异常仅通过头颅侧位X线片无法诊断。仅5例患者(0.5%)因颅骨X线片检查发现的异常在CT检查中未被检测到而导致治疗方案被积极改变。因此,对于患有中风、癫痫、痴呆或无局灶体征的非特异性症状的非创伤患者,或最近接受过开颅手术且已转诊进行CT检查的患者,颅骨X线片检查是不合理的。对于有病史和检查结果强烈提示蝶鞍、小脑脑桥角和鼻窦以外任何部位存在病理疾病的患者,仅在CT检查结果不明确时,才应在CT检查后拍摄头颅侧位X线片。