Gullo D F, Bersani C
Percept Mot Skills. 1983 Apr;56(2):675-8. doi: 10.2466/pms.1983.56.2.675.
60 3-, 4-, and 5-yr.-old children were asked to coordinate visual perspectives in three conditions: (1) Piaget and Inhelder's "Three Mountain Task," (2) identify objects a doll could see against the side of two intersecting walls, and (3) choose a picture which represented which objects the doll could see. Both condition and age effects were significant. For all age groups there were significant differences between the "Three Mountain Task" and the other two tasks, with significantly more children responding correctly on the two object-identification conditions. No significant differences between the two object-identification conditions were found. While 5-yr.-olds performed significantly better on both object-identification conditions, no differences were found between the 3- and 4-yr.-olds on these tasks. No age effect was found on the "Three Mountain Task." Children of all groups found this task too difficult. 3-, 4-, and 5-yr.-olds seem better at coordinating visual perspectives than suggested earlier. Greater success on present tasks may be due to the reduced number of visual cues that represented alternate visual perspectives. Differences in cognitive demands of each condition were analyzed.
研究人员要求60名3岁、4岁和5岁的儿童在三种情境下协调视觉视角:(1)皮亚杰和英海尔德的“三山任务”;(2)识别一个玩偶在两面相交墙壁一侧所能看到的物体;(3)选择一幅代表玩偶能看到哪些物体的图片。情境和年龄效应均显著。对于所有年龄组,“三山任务”与其他两项任务之间存在显著差异,在两项物体识别情境中,做出正确反应的儿童明显更多。未发现两项物体识别情境之间存在显著差异。虽然5岁儿童在两项物体识别情境中的表现均显著更好,但在这些任务上,3岁和4岁儿童之间未发现差异。在“三山任务”上未发现年龄效应。所有组的儿童都觉得这项任务太难。3岁、4岁和5岁的儿童在协调视觉视角方面似乎比之前认为的更好。当前任务取得更大成功可能是由于代表不同视觉视角的视觉线索数量减少。研究人员分析了每种情境下认知需求的差异。