Andreasen N C, Akiskal H S
Psychiatr Clin North Am. 1983 Mar;6(1):41-54.
Schneider's FRS's seem to carry diagnostic weight for schizophrenia when "massively" present and when known organic psychoses are excluded. However, at least 10 per cent of affectively ill probands, especially manics, have also been shown to have at least one FRS. The main problems in their clinical application is their low sensitivity (on the average less than 50 per cent), and the possibility that those without extensive training in the phenomenologic approach may overendorse their presence, thereby diluting the specificity of the test.
当“大量”存在且排除已知的器质性精神障碍时,施奈德一级症状似乎对精神分裂症具有诊断价值。然而,至少10%的情感障碍先证者,尤其是躁狂症患者,也被证明至少有一项一级症状。其临床应用中的主要问题是敏感性低(平均低于50%),以及未经现象学方法广泛训练的人可能过度认定其存在,从而降低了该测试的特异性。