Shea J J
Ann Otol Rhinol Laryngol. 1982 Sep-Oct;91(5 Pt 1):516-20. doi: 10.1177/000348948209100510.
The long-term results with large fenestra stapedectomy with vein graft and Teflon piston are compared with results with the small fenestra stapedectomy with teflon piston directly into the vestibule. There were 1,943 operations in the former group and 2,155 in the latter when compared in 1970. One hundred consecutive patients from the beginning of each group with follow-up to present were compared. Results were generally the same with no great change in 15 and 20 years as compared to those at 5 years. The complication of perilymph fistula was caused by creating an opening in the footplate much larger than the prosthesis and was eliminated by interposing a living oval window seal if the opening was much larger than the prosthesis and a flap of lining membrane from the promontory when it was not. Other factors that influence a good result are discussed, including the type and the diameter of the piston used, the type of living oval window seal and the method of attachment to the incus. The small fenestra operation was found to be superior to the large, not only for the hearing gain achieved, but the case of performance and the freedom from complications due to migration of the prosthesis and/or the oval window seal. At present we have done about all that can be done for the conductive components. What remains is the sensorineural component which our studies indicate may be due to an autoimmune response.
将大窗镫骨切除术联合静脉移植和聚四氟乙烯活塞的长期结果与小窗镫骨切除术(直接将聚四氟乙烯活塞植入前庭)的结果进行比较。1970年比较时,前一组有1943例手术,后一组有2155例手术。对每组从开始起连续100例有随访至今的患者进行比较。结果总体相同,15年和20年时与5年时相比没有太大变化。外淋巴瘘并发症是由于在镫骨足板上制造的开口比假体大得多所致,如果开口比假体大得多,则通过插入活的椭圆窗密封物来消除,如果开口不比假体大,则通过插入来自岬的衬里膜瓣来消除。还讨论了影响良好结果的其他因素,包括所用活塞的类型和直径、活的椭圆窗密封物的类型以及与砧骨的连接方法。发现小窗手术优于大窗手术,不仅在听力改善方面,而且在操作简便性以及避免因假体和/或椭圆窗密封物移位导致的并发症方面。目前,我们已经对传导性成分做了几乎所有能做的事情。剩下的是感觉神经性成分,我们的研究表明这可能是由于自身免疫反应所致。