King H, Locke F B
J Natl Cancer Inst. 1980 Nov;65(5):1115-24.
An examination of 28,134 clergymen in five predominantly white Protestant denominations, 1950--60, showed a more favorable mortality for these clergymen for all causes of deaths, total cancers, and cardiovascular-renal diseases compared with the mortality for U.S. white males, total U.S. males with work experience, and total U.S. white clergymen. The standardized mortality ratios for cancer of the lung and non-motor-vehicle accidents were particularly depressed. However, those for diabetes, leukemia, and cancers of the prostate gland and, to a lesser extent, lymphoma and cancers of the intestine and pancreas were not significantly different from 100. The findings were interpreted in the social class contest, with emphasis on cross-national investigations and critical assessment of clerical statistics.
1950年至1960年期间,对五个主要为白人新教教派的28134名神职人员进行的一项调查显示,与美国白人男性、有工作经验的美国男性总数以及美国白人神职人员总数相比,这些神职人员在所有死因、所有癌症以及心血管-肾脏疾病方面的死亡率更低。肺癌和非机动车辆事故的标准化死亡率尤其低。然而,糖尿病、白血病、前列腺癌以及程度较轻的淋巴瘤、肠道癌和胰腺癌的标准化死亡率与100没有显著差异。这些发现是在社会阶层背景下进行解释的,重点是跨国调查和对神职人员统计数据的批判性评估。