Steadman H J, Vanderwyst D, Ribner S
Am J Psychiatry. 1978 Oct;135(10):1218-20. doi: 10.1176/ajp.135.10.1218.
The authors compared the arrest rates of former mental patients with those of criminal offenders released in the same jurisdiction. The data for all ex-patients and all offenders released in Albany County, New York, in 1968 and 1975 support the contention that it is the relationship between prior and subsequent arrests that explains the increasing crime rate of ex-patients and the three to six times higher rate of arrest of released offenders. Since the three-quarters of former patients with no arrest records were arrested about as often as the general population and substantially less often than offenders, care is warranted in drawing inferences from overall mental patient arrest rates.
作者将曾经的精神病患者的逮捕率与在同一司法管辖区获释的刑事罪犯的逮捕率进行了比较。1968年和1975年在纽约奥尔巴尼县获释的所有前患者和所有罪犯的数据支持了这样一种观点,即先前和随后被捕之间的关系解释了前患者犯罪率的上升以及获释罪犯高出三到六倍的逮捕率。由于四分之三没有逮捕记录的前患者被捕的频率与普通人群大致相同,且远低于罪犯,因此在从总体精神病患者逮捕率得出推论时应谨慎。