Hörnquist J O
Scand J Soc Med. 1982;10(3):113-8. doi: 10.1177/140349488201000308.
Social reforms are often introduced solely on the basis of theoretical considerations without any empirical research. Thus, it is often an urgent matter to evaluate the real effects of a reform. In this investigation, the increased possibilities for abusers to obtain disability pensions that came into force in Sweden 1977-01-01 have been examined. A representative sample of 15 percent of all applications in the county of Ostergötland in 1975 has been compared with a corresponding one in 1978. As expected, the number of abusers of alcohol among the applicants increased. The proportion of male abusers rose from 13.5 in 1975 to 22 percent in 1978. Despite a levelling off of differences in the civil status in 1978, the abusers were still in a substantially weaker social position than the other applicants. In contrast to the other applicants, no traces of increased efforts towards vocational rehabilitation can be noted among the abusers in 1978. This is quite remarkable since, according to the preceding official report, liberalization was not meant to replace meaningful efforts of rehabilitation. In 1978, the whole group of applicants were younger and they lived more frequently in large, densely populated areas. Furthermore, the number of women increased so that they were in a majority among the applicants in 1978. These changes probably reflect structural changes in society, especially in the labour market. This is the final report of an independent study in the research project "Abuse of alcohol - Disability pension - Quality of life".
社会改革往往仅基于理论考量而推行,未经过任何实证研究。因此,评估一项改革的实际效果常常是当务之急。在本次调查中,研究了1977年1月1日在瑞典生效的、酗酒者获得残疾抚恤金可能性增加的情况。选取了东约特兰省1975年所有申请的15%作为具有代表性的样本,并与1978年的相应样本进行了比较。不出所料,申请者中酗酒者的数量有所增加。男性酗酒者的比例从1975年的13.5%升至1978年的22%。尽管1978年在婚姻状况方面的差异趋于平稳,但酗酒者的社会地位仍比其他申请者低得多。与其他申请者不同,1978年酗酒者中没有迹象显示他们在职业康复方面做出了更多努力。这相当值得注意,因为根据之前的官方报告,放宽政策并非旨在取代有意义的康复努力。1978年,所有申请者群体更年轻,且他们更频繁地居住在人口密集的大城市地区。此外,女性申请者数量增加,以至于在1978年的申请者中占多数。这些变化可能反映了社会结构的变化,尤其是劳动力市场的变化。这是研究项目“酗酒——残疾抚恤金——生活质量”中一项独立研究的最终报告。