Waring G O, Krohn M A, Ford G E, Harris R R, Rosenblatt L S
Arch Ophthalmol. 1980 May;98(5):848-55. doi: 10.1001/archopht.1980.01020030842008.
We measured central corneal endothelial cell density and area from contact specular photomicrographs of ten normal and ten abnormal corneas, comparing the precision, cost, and speed of four methods: a rectangle, planimeter, digitizer, and cell sizer. The rectangle, planimeter, and digitizer gave results that differed less than 10% from each other; therefore, the three methods can be used interchangeably for clinical purposes. There are statistically significant differences among the three techniques that may be important in basic research. The cell sizer gave a rapid, less precise estimate of mean cell area and cell density. The planimeter and digitizer measured individual endothelial cell size, and the latter entered data directly into a computer that printed both a copy of the endothelial mosaic and a histogram of cell size frequency, and computed cell density and mean cell area. We make the following recommendations: Count cells in a rectangle used for routine clinical measurement. use a cell sizer for rough estimation, as in an eyebank setting. Use a computerized digitizer to study individual endothelial cell size.
我们从10只正常角膜和10只异常角膜的接触式镜面显微镜照片中测量了中央角膜内皮细胞密度和面积,比较了四种方法的精度、成本和速度:矩形法、面积计法、数字化仪法和细胞大小测量仪法。矩形法、面积计法和数字化仪法得出的结果相互之间差异小于10%;因此,这三种方法可在临床应用中互换使用。这三种技术之间存在统计学上的显著差异,这在基础研究中可能很重要。细胞大小测量仪对平均细胞面积和细胞密度的估计快速但不太精确。面积计和数字化仪测量单个内皮细胞的大小,后者将数据直接输入计算机,计算机打印出内皮镶嵌图副本和细胞大小频率直方图,并计算细胞密度和平均细胞面积。我们提出以下建议:在用于常规临床测量的矩形中计数细胞。在眼库环境中,使用细胞大小测量仪进行粗略估计。使用计算机化数字化仪研究单个内皮细胞的大小。