Ahlfors U G, Dencker S J, Gravem A, Remvig J
Acta Psychiatr Scand Suppl. 1980;279:77-91. doi: 10.1111/j.1600-0447.1980.tb07085.x.
The clinical properties of clopenthixol decanoate has been investigated versus perphenazine enanthate in a double-blind clinical multicentre trial including 14 psychiatric hospitals in Finland, Sweden, Norway, and Denmark. Test treatment was initiated in 172 chronic schizophrenic patients and the planned 6 months test period was completed by 57 patients receiving clopenthixol decanoate and 48 receiving perphenazine enanthate. The therapeutic effect was assessed by means of CGI, BPRS, and NOSIE-30 and was found significant with both test drugs. Significant differences in the effect were seen only in "Hostile-suspiciousness" (BPRS) and "Social interest" (NOSIE-30). For these items clopenthixol decanoate was found superior to perphenazine enanthate. The influence of side effects on the patients' functioning was found to be slightly, but not significantly more troublesome in the perphenazine enanthate patients.
在一项双盲临床多中心试验中,对癸酸氯哌噻吨和庚酸奋乃静的临床特性进行了研究,该试验涉及芬兰、瑞典、挪威和丹麦的14家精神病医院。172名慢性精神分裂症患者开始接受试验治疗,在计划的6个月试验期结束时,57名患者接受了癸酸氯哌噻吨治疗,48名患者接受了庚酸奋乃静治疗。通过临床总体印象量表(CGI)、简明精神病评定量表(BPRS)和护士观察量表(NOSIE-30)评估治疗效果,发现两种试验药物均有显著疗效。仅在“敌对-猜疑”(BPRS)和“社会兴趣”(NOSIE-30)方面观察到疗效存在显著差异。对于这些项目,发现癸酸氯哌噻吨优于庚酸奋乃静。研究发现,副作用对患者功能的影响在庚酸奋乃静组患者中略显麻烦,但差异不显著。