Jones G E, Evans P A
Biol Psychol. 1981 Jun;12(4):313-20. doi: 10.1016/0301-0511(81)90005-3.
Although it is common for EMG frontalis feedback to be used to train general relaxation, there is a growing literature that challenges its use. This experiment explored whether successful frontalis EMG training produces concomitant covariation of autonomic nervous system indicators of decreased arousal and tension for highly anxious subjects. Twenty-four subjects were divided into groups receiving either frontalis feedback training, motivated constant-tone control, or motivated self-relaxation control procedures. Analysis showed that feedback training led to significantly lower frontalis levels, but similar effects were not found for heart rate, skin conductance levels, or respiration rate. The results suggest that even successful EMG frontalis feedback is not accompanied by anticipated reduction in related physiological descriptors. The use of frontalis tension level as an index of general tension is also discussed.
虽然使用额肌肌电图反馈来训练全身放松很常见,但越来越多的文献对其使用提出了质疑。本实验探讨了成功的额肌肌电图训练是否会使高度焦虑的受试者的自主神经系统指标伴随唤醒和紧张程度降低而产生共变。24名受试者被分为接受额肌反馈训练、激励性持续音调控制或激励性自我放松控制程序的组。分析表明,反馈训练导致额肌水平显著降低,但心率、皮肤电导率水平或呼吸频率未发现类似效果。结果表明,即使是成功的额肌肌电图反馈也不会伴随着相关生理指标的预期降低。还讨论了将额肌紧张水平用作全身紧张指标的问题。