McIntosh I D
Int J Addict. 1982 May;17(4):609-39. doi: 10.3109/10826088209053007.
Thirty-one publications containing estimates of the prevalence of alcohol-related problems within general hospitals are assessed critically to determine whether the alcohol dependence syndrome or other alcohol-related disabilities were the subjects of study, and whether these were causal to admission or incidental findings. A classification scheme within which these studies may be fitted is introduced, and an attempt is made to gauge the sizes of the problems by collating results within each classification category. No consistency is found, however; and this is attributed to difficulties of definition as well as to deficiencies in survey techniques. Some suggestions for better-designed studies are made. Until these are carried out it will not be possible to provide valid to reliable estimates of the extent of the problem.
对31篇包含综合医院内酒精相关问题患病率估计的出版物进行了批判性评估,以确定酒精依赖综合征或其他酒精相关残疾是否为研究对象,以及这些是入院的原因还是偶然发现。引入了一个可将这些研究纳入的分类方案,并试图通过整理每个分类类别中的结果来衡量问题的规模。然而,未发现一致性;这归因于定义困难以及调查技术的缺陷。提出了一些关于设计更好研究的建议。在进行这些研究之前,将无法提供关于该问题程度的有效可靠估计。