Subramanian B, Bowles M J, Davies A B, Raftery E B
Am J Cardiol. 1982 Jan;49(1):125-32. doi: 10.1016/0002-9149(82)90286-7.
The comparative efficacy of verapamil (360 mg daily) and propranolol (240 mg daily) was evaluated with computerized treadmill exercise in 22 patients with chronic stable angina in a placebo-controlled double-blind crossover study with 4 weeks on each active phase. Fourteen of these patients still had angina despite active drug therapy and they were further treated with a combination of verapamil (360 mg) and propranolol (120 mg) for 4 weeks. The mean exercise time for these patients taking placebo was 4.8 +/- 0.22 minutes (mean +/- standard error of the mean) and this increased to 6.8 +/- 0.64 minutes with propranolol and 8.0 +/- 0.5 minutes with verapamil. A further increase to 10.1 +/- 0.88 minutes was observed with the combination of both drugs and seven patients became symptom-free. S-T segment criteria improved with both drugs, and combination therapy produced a further reduction in peak S-T depression. Electrocardiographic ambulatory monitoring showed no evidence of conduction defects and mean hourly heart rates were similar to those seen with propranolol alone. Left ventricular function indexes were not significantly different from those obtained with propranolol. Combination therapy with verapamil and propranolol appears to be efficacious in the treatment of selected patients with severe chronic stable angina. The patients need to be carefully monitored for adverse effects.
在一项安慰剂对照的双盲交叉研究中,对22例慢性稳定型心绞痛患者使用计算机化跑步机运动评估了维拉帕米(每日360毫克)和普萘洛尔(每日240毫克)的比较疗效,每个活性期持续4周。这些患者中有14例尽管接受了积极的药物治疗仍有心绞痛,他们进一步接受了维拉帕米(360毫克)和普萘洛尔(120毫克)联合治疗4周。服用安慰剂的这些患者的平均运动时间为4.8±0.22分钟(平均值±平均值的标准误差),使用普萘洛尔时增加到6.8±0.64分钟,使用维拉帕米时增加到8.0±0.5分钟。两种药物联合使用时进一步增加到10.1±0.88分钟,7例患者症状消失。两种药物均使S-T段标准得到改善,联合治疗使S-T段峰值压低进一步降低。动态心电图监测未显示传导缺陷的证据,平均每小时心率与单独使用普萘洛尔时相似。左心室功能指标与使用普萘洛尔时无显著差异。维拉帕米和普萘洛尔联合治疗似乎对治疗某些严重慢性稳定型心绞痛患者有效。需要对患者进行仔细的不良反应监测。