Spence J D, Donner A
Stroke. 1982 Jan-Feb;13(1):94-9. doi: 10.1161/01.str.13.1.94.
Critical evaluation of the literature was use to identify remediable flaws in the design of clinical trials of stroke treatment. Trials of dexamethasone, dextran, and glycerol were reviewed. Available studies have in common major weaknesses in case selection (failure to exclude arteriolar strokes due to hemorrhage or lacunar infarction), and failure to estimate required sample size. Problems of case selection can be avoided with computerized tomography; the sample size required to show superiority of active treatment over placebo can be estimated using standard formulas. Prognostic stratification is suggested as a method of overcoming problems of unbalanced allocation. Further studies with improved design are required to evaluate the prospects for medical limitation of cerebral infarct size.
对文献进行批判性评估,以确定中风治疗临床试验设计中可补救的缺陷。回顾了地塞米松、右旋糖酐和甘油的试验。现有研究在病例选择方面存在共同的主要弱点(未能排除因出血或腔隙性梗死导致的小动脉中风),以及未能估计所需样本量。计算机断层扫描可以避免病例选择问题;使用标准公式可以估计显示活性治疗优于安慰剂所需的样本量。建议采用预后分层作为克服不均衡分配问题的一种方法。需要进行设计改进的进一步研究,以评估医学限制脑梗死大小的前景。