Keene J S, Goletz T H, Lilleas F, Alter A J, Sackett J F
J Bone Joint Surg Am. 1982 Apr;64(4):586-94.
Thirty patients with acute thoracic, lumbar, or thoracolumbar fractures, dislocations, or fracture-dislocations were evaluated with standard radiographs, conventional polytomography, and computerized axial tomography. The resulting ninety studies were coded, randomized, and independently interpreted by three radiologists. The diagnostic accuracy of the interpretations based on the computerized tomography scans combined with standard radiographs equaled that of the interpretations based on just the tomograms in the evaluation of fractures of posterior elements. In addition, computerized tomography was superior to the other methods in demonstrating impingement on the neural canal as well as injuries to other organ systems. Also, when compared with conventional polytomography, computerized tomography could be completed with less risk to the patient (no changes in position and ten times less radiation). We concluded that computerized tomography should replace conventional polytomography as the initial study to augment standard radiographs in the assessment of thoracic and lumbar fractures. Conventional polytomography should be reserved for patients in whom precise evaluation of the pars interarticularis is deemed necessary.
对30例急性胸段、腰段或胸腰段骨折、脱位或骨折脱位患者进行了标准X线片、传统断层摄影术和计算机断层扫描检查。由此产生的90份研究资料进行了编码、随机分组,并由三位放射科医生独立解读。在评估后部结构骨折时,基于计算机断层扫描结合标准X线片的解读诊断准确性与仅基于断层摄影的解读相当。此外,在显示对神经根管的压迫以及其他器官系统损伤方面,计算机断层扫描优于其他方法。而且,与传统断层摄影术相比,计算机断层扫描检查对患者的风险更小(无需改变体位,辐射剂量减少十分之九)。我们得出结论,在评估胸腰椎骨折时,计算机断层扫描应取代传统断层摄影术作为增强标准X线片的初始检查方法。传统断层摄影术应保留用于那些认为有必要对关节突间部进行精确评估的患者。