Fuller L M, Hutchison G B
Cancer Treat Rep. 1982 Apr;66(4):775-87.
In this study, 460 eligible patients with stage I and II Hodgkin's disease were randomized to treatment with involved field (IF) and extended field (EF) radiotherapy. Lymphangiogram was a requisite of the study. One hundred and seventy-seven patients were staged by laparotomy. The value of EF radiotherapy in improving survival over a 10-year followup was studied. This effect was considered separately for patents staged by laparotomy, for patients staged by lymphangiogram alone, and for patients with and without initial mediastinal involvement. A substantial benefit was seen for the subgroup staged by lymphangiogram alone and without mediastinal disease, with 10-year survival rates of 80% for EF and 56% for IF. For all other groups staged by laparotomy or having mediastinal presentations 10-year survival rates were essentially the same, differing by less than ten percentage points for IF and EF regimens. The advantage of EF treatment in lymphangiogram-staged nonmediastinal disease was realized only when the extended fields included the abdominal para-aortic area.
在本研究中,460例符合条件的Ⅰ期和Ⅱ期霍奇金病患者被随机分为累及野(IF)放疗组和扩大野(EF)放疗组。淋巴造影是本研究的必要条件。177例患者通过剖腹探查进行分期。研究了EF放疗在10年随访期内对提高生存率的作用。分别对经剖腹探查分期的患者、仅经淋巴造影分期的患者以及有和无初始纵隔受累的患者进行了该效应分析。仅经淋巴造影分期且无纵隔疾病的亚组患者有显著获益,EF组10年生存率为80%,IF组为56%。对于所有其他经剖腹探查分期或有纵隔表现的组,10年生存率基本相同,IF和EF方案相差不到10个百分点。只有当扩大野包括腹主动脉旁区域时,EF治疗在淋巴造影分期的非纵隔疾病中才显示出优势。