Nugent W C, Levine F H, Liapis C D, LaRaia P J, Tsai C H, Buckley M J
Circulation. 1982 Aug;66(2 Pt 2):I68-72.
The assumption that an alkaline cardioplegic solution is advantageous to the arrested heart is not supported by experimental evidence. Three groups of dogs were subjected to 2 hours of hypothermic arrest using a potassium cardioplegic solution of varying pH: group 1 (n = 8), pH 7.1; group 2 (n = 6), pH 7.4; and group 3 (n = 8), pH 7.7. Left ventricular (LV) function curves were obtained before arrest and after reperfusion, and the percent recovery of LV function was calculated. Coronary blood flow (CBF), oxygen and lactate use, and adenosine triphosphate and creatine phosphate were measured before and after arrest. Recovery of LV function was 83 +/- 4% (mean +/- SEM) in group 1 and 75 +/- 6% in group 2. LV function in group 3 was significantly depressed at 51 +/- 5% (p less than 0.01). Immediately after arrest, CBF and oxygen consumption were lowest in group 1 and highest in group 3 (p less than 0.01). CBF increased 23 +/- 9% in group 1, 110 +/- 29% in group 2 and 277 +/- 33% in group 3. Oxygen consumption was 2.2 +/- 0.4 vol/100 g/min in group 1, 3.63 +/- 0.5 vol/100 g/min in group 2 and 4.63 +/- 0.7 vol/100 g/min in group 3. All groups showed postarrest depression of adenosine triphosphate and creatine phosphate, but return of creatine phosphate to control was slowest in group 1 (p less than 0.01). These results indicate no advantage to an alkaline cardioplegic solution and suggest that an acidic cardioplegic solution, by inhibiting metabolism, may increase protection of the arrested heart.
碱性心脏停搏液对心脏停搏有益这一假设并未得到实验证据的支持。三组犬使用不同pH值的钾心脏停搏液进行2小时低温停搏:第1组(n = 8),pH值7.1;第2组(n = 6),pH值7.4;第3组(n = 8),pH值7.7。在停搏前和再灌注后获取左心室(LV)功能曲线,并计算LV功能的恢复百分比。在停搏前后测量冠状动脉血流量(CBF)、氧和乳酸利用情况以及三磷酸腺苷和磷酸肌酸。第1组LV功能恢复为83±4%(均值±标准误),第2组为75±6%。第3组LV功能显著降低至51±5%(p<0.01)。停搏后即刻,第1组CBF和氧消耗最低,第3组最高(p<0.01)。第1组CBF增加23±9%,第2组增加110±29%,第3组增加277±33%。第1组氧消耗为2.2±0.4 vol/100 g/min,第2组为3.63±0.5 vol/100 g/min,第3组为4.63±0.7 vol/100 g/min。所有组均显示停搏后三磷酸腺苷和磷酸肌酸降低,但第1组磷酸肌酸恢复至对照水平最慢(p<0.01)。这些结果表明碱性心脏停搏液并无优势,并提示酸性心脏停搏液通过抑制代谢可能增加对停搏心脏的保护。