Comstock E G, Boisaubin E V, Comstock B S, Faulkner T P
J Toxicol Clin Toxicol. 1982 Apr;19(2):149-65. doi: 10.3109/15563658208990377.
The efficacy of administering a slurry of 100 g of activated charcoal (AC) via the gastric tube following lavage was assessed in 25 treated and 37 control patients presenting to the emergency room with chemical evidence of sedative-hypnotics or aspirin in the blood. Efficacy was evaluated as the ability of AC to prevent further absorption as determined by subsequent blood drug concentration changes. Although fewer patients in the AC group showed increased blood drug concentrations, the differences were not statistically significant. Comparison of the mean percent change in blood drug concentrations at various times following treatment produced similar results. Comparisons using subgroups of patients based on the individual drugs, the treatment delay time, and entering functional decompensation showed significant benefit from AC only in the less symptomatic patients. Comparing these results with other studies demonstrating the unequivocal efficacy of early (e.g., 30 min) treatment, it is concluded that the use of AC following lavage may often be too late to benefit most patients. The authors suggest that AC be given in the home, emergency vehicle, or immediately upon admission.
对25例接受治疗的患者和37例对照患者进行了评估,这些患者因血液中有镇静催眠药或阿司匹林的化学证据而到急诊室就诊,在洗胃后通过胃管给予100克活性炭(AC)混悬液。疗效评估为根据随后的血药浓度变化确定的AC预防进一步吸收的能力。尽管AC组中血药浓度升高的患者较少,但差异无统计学意义。治疗后不同时间血药浓度平均变化百分比的比较产生了类似结果。根据个体药物、治疗延迟时间和进入功能失代偿情况对患者亚组进行比较,结果显示仅在症状较轻的患者中AC有显著益处。将这些结果与其他表明早期(如30分钟)治疗明确有效的研究进行比较后得出结论,洗胃后使用AC对大多数患者可能往往为时已晚。作者建议在家庭、急救车上或入院后立即给予AC。