Martin R B, Moltmann M L
J Clin Psychol. 1978 Oct;34(4):876-83. doi: 10.1002/1097-4679(197810)34:4<876::aid-jclp2270340410>3.0.co;2-p.
Investigated the effects of verbal reinforcement paradigms on hospitalized schizophrenics and staff. Positive reinforcement that involved good was found to be relatively ineffective for all groups; furthermore, associating good with the termination of a white noise did not increase its effectiveness for schizophrenics. Verbal punishment was more effective than verbal positive reinforcement for staff, but for schizophrenics only when explicit problem-solving instructions were given. The results suggest that the reduction of deficit is not more likely via verbal punishment; if anything, deficit is increased because of increased staff performance under verbal punishment.
研究了言语强化范式对住院精神分裂症患者及医护人员的影响。结果发现,涉及表扬的正强化对所有群体相对无效;此外,将表扬与白噪音的终止联系起来,对精神分裂症患者而言并没有提高其有效性。言语惩罚对医护人员比言语正强化更有效,但对精神分裂症患者而言,只有在给出明确的解决问题的指导时才有效。结果表明,通过言语惩罚不太可能减少缺陷;如果有什么影响的话,由于言语惩罚下医护人员表现的提高,缺陷反而增加了。