Hibberd T, Trimboli F
Hosp Community Psychiatry. 1982 Oct;33(10):829-33. doi: 10.1176/ps.33.10.829.
The increased popularity of short-term psychiatric hospitalization has raised the question of what kinds of patients benefit most from this treatment. The authors examined the records of 612 patients admitted to an urban general hospital's psychiatric inpatient unit over two years; all subjects had been referred by the hospital's psychiatric emergency room. A total of 156 clinical variables and 18 demographic variables recorded on the emergency room's intake form were examined and correlated with treatment outcome in terms of length of inpatient stay and disposition on discharge, as recorded on discharge records. A total of 21 clinical variables were found to be positively or negatively related to patient discharge into the community within 21 days after admission. None of the demographic features studied were unequivocally related to that outcome measure. The authors suggest that less severely ill patients may respond better (and thus have better treatment outcomes) than more debilitated ones, or that patients who recognize and acknowledge their distress may be better candidates for crisis-oriented short-term treatment.
短期精神科住院治疗日益普及,引发了何种患者能从这种治疗中获益最大的问题。作者查阅了一家城市综合医院精神科住院部两年内收治的612例患者的记录;所有受试者均由医院精神科急诊室转诊而来。研究了急诊室入院表格上记录的总共156项临床变量和18项人口统计学变量,并将其与出院记录中所记录的住院时间和出院处置等治疗结果进行关联分析。结果发现,共有21项临床变量与患者入院后21天内出院回归社区呈正相关或负相关。所研究的人口统计学特征中,无一与该结果指标明确相关。作者认为,病情不太严重的患者可能比病情更虚弱的患者反应更好(从而治疗效果更佳),或者认识并承认自身痛苦的患者可能更适合接受以危机为导向的短期治疗。