Morgenstern H
Am J Public Health. 1982 Dec;72(12):1336-44. doi: 10.2105/ajph.72.12.1336.
Despite the widespread use of ecologic analysis in epidemiologic research and health planning, little attention has been given by health scientists and practitioners to the methodological aspects of this approach. This paper reviews the major types of ecologic study designs, the analytic methods appropriate for each, the limitations of ecologic data for making causal inferences and what can be done to minimize these problems, and the relative advantages of ecologic analysis. Numerous examples are provided to illustrate the important principles and methods. A careful distinction is made between ecologic studies that generate or test etiologic hypotheses and those that evaluate the impact of intervention programs or policies (given adequate knowledge of disease etiology). Failure to recognize this difference in the conduct of ecologic studies can lead to results that are not very informative or that are misinterpreted by others.
尽管生态分析在流行病学研究和健康规划中得到广泛应用,但健康科学家和从业者对这种方法的方法论方面关注甚少。本文回顾了主要的生态研究设计类型、适用于每种设计的分析方法、生态数据在进行因果推断时的局限性以及如何尽量减少这些问题,还有生态分析的相对优势。文中提供了大量示例来说明重要的原则和方法。在产生或检验病因假设的生态研究与评估干预项目或政策影响的生态研究(在对疾病病因有充分了解的情况下)之间进行了仔细区分。在生态研究中未能认识到这种差异可能会导致结果缺乏足够信息或被他人误解。