Masterton G, Gallagher J, Timbury G C
Scott Med J. 1982 Oct;27(4):318-22. doi: 10.1177/003693308202700411.
The factors determining the use of Section 31 admissions and reclassifications at a district psychiatric hospital were investigated prospectively over an eight month period. Thirty-six per cent of patients failed to meet the criteria laid down for full detention and, particularly with reclassification, Section 31 was invoked to secure treatment. While the Emergency Recommendation is not used as the legislators intended, a seven day detention order appears more relevant to modern psychiatric practice than the full detention procedure.
在八个月的时间里,对一家地区精神病医院使用第31条规定的收治和重新分类的决定因素进行了前瞻性调查。36%的患者不符合完全拘留规定的标准,特别是在重新分类时,援引第31条规定以确保治疗。虽然紧急建议的使用并非如立法者所愿,但七天拘留令似乎比完全拘留程序更符合现代精神病学实践。