Amador M, Rodriguez C, González M E, Bacallao J
Acta Paediatr Acad Sci Hung. 1982;23(4):381-90.
Anthropometric measurements in one hundred girls and one hundred boys from 4.6 to 5.5 years of age were carried out in order to study the correspondence between the criteria of obesity according to weight for stature (BW-HT) and according to the magnitude of fat body mass (FM calculated of two different regression equations, one developed starting from body weight (BW), height (HT) and two skinfolds, and another one, using only BW and HT. Employing the criterion of obesity based upon BW-HT above 120%, a number of heavy but not fatty subjects (mainly boys) were included as obese, and three of the girls studied were fatty but not overweight. Conversely, if we calculate FM using the regression equation based on BW and HT, and the criterion of obesity based upon body fat percent, the incidence of obesity could be underestimated. The best results were given by regression equations which include BW, HT and two skinfolds (triceps and subscapular). Though the usefulness of BW and HT in nutritional assessment is not discussed, the diagnostic limitations of these measurements used alone or in combination are evident and therefore it is necessary to include skinfold measurements if we wish to obtain a correct diagnosis of obesity.
对100名4.6至5.5岁的女孩和100名男孩进行了人体测量,以研究根据身高体重(BW-HT)和脂肪量(通过两个不同回归方程计算得出的FM,一个从体重(BW)、身高(HT)和两个皮褶厚度推导而来,另一个仅使用BW和HT)判断肥胖标准之间的对应关系。采用高于120%的BW-HT作为肥胖标准时,一些体重较重但不肥胖的受试者(主要是男孩)被归类为肥胖,且所研究的女孩中有三人脂肪含量高但体重未超重。相反,如果使用基于BW和HT的回归方程计算FM,并以体脂百分比作为肥胖标准,肥胖发生率可能会被低估。包含BW、HT和两个皮褶厚度(肱三头肌和肩胛下)的回归方程得出的结果最佳。尽管未讨论BW和HT在营养评估中的作用,但单独或联合使用这些测量方法的诊断局限性是明显的,因此,如果我们希望正确诊断肥胖,有必要纳入皮褶厚度测量。