Donahue M, Pearl R, Bryan T
J Speech Hear Disord. 1982 Nov;47(4):397-403. doi: 10.1044/jshd.4704.397.
Previous studies have generally examined learning disabled children's syntactic ability either on structured tasks or by analyzing oral language samples collected under conditions not typical of natural communicative settings. Thus, these studies are of limited value in exploring the impact of learning disabled children's deficits in linguistic structure on their use of language in social contexts. The purpose of this study was to investigate learning disabled children's syntactic proficiency during a task requiring them to convey information to a listener. Subjects were selected on the bases of teacher ratings, reading achievement scores, and Peabody Picture Vocabulary Test IQ scores within the normal range; those children identified as learning disabled received low ratings and demonstrated underachievement (below 40th percentile for their grade) in reading. Oral language samples were collected by having learning disabled and normally achieving children in grades two, four, six, and eight participate in a referential communication task in which they described abstract shapes to an experimenter. The length and syntactic complexity of the children's descriptions were assessed. Learning disabled children in all grades were found to produce shorter mean t-units and shorter mean main clauses than nondisabled children even on this relatively simple communicative task. Although learning disabled children's linguistic problems have previously been characterized as subtle, these findings suggest that their productive language deficits may be significant enough to interfere with even the informal and elliptical conversations characteristic of communication among peers and family members.
以往的研究通常是在结构化任务中,或者通过分析在非自然交流环境下收集的口语样本来考察学习障碍儿童的句法能力。因此,这些研究在探索学习障碍儿童语言结构缺陷对其在社会情境中语言运用的影响方面价值有限。本研究的目的是调查学习障碍儿童在向听众传达信息的任务中的句法熟练程度。研究对象是根据教师评分、阅读成绩以及皮博迪图片词汇测试智商分数在正常范围内挑选出来的;那些被认定为学习障碍的儿童得到的评分较低,并且在阅读方面表现不佳(低于同年级第40百分位)。通过让二、四、六、八年级的学习障碍儿童和成绩正常的儿童参与一项指称性交流任务来收集口语样本,在该任务中,他们向一名实验者描述抽象形状。对儿童描述的长度和句法复杂性进行了评估。结果发现,即使在这项相对简单的交流任务中,所有年级的学习障碍儿童所产出的平均t单位和平均主句都比非学习障碍儿童短。尽管学习障碍儿童的语言问题以前被描述为不明显,但这些发现表明,他们在语言产出方面的缺陷可能严重到足以干扰同龄人及家庭成员之间交流中典型的非正式和省略性对话。