Carpenter W T, Heinrichs D W
J Nerv Ment Dis. 1981 Feb;169(2):113-9. doi: 10.1097/00005053-198102000-00006.
The heterogeneity of schizophrenia and the failure of classical subtypes to predict treatment response reliably have led to two contrasting assumptions. The first is that the treatment approach is essentially the same for all schizophrenics. The second is that the treatment needs of schizophrenic patients can be based only on clinical "hunches" or the biases of the therapist, because meaningful criteria for making therapeutic decisions are lacking. Both assumptions tend to discourage careful and critically reasoned treatment planning. This report argues that current knowledge permits the formulation of subtypes that can assist in the rational choice of individualized treatment approaches. It proffers a number of such subtypes and deals with their application to therapeutic decision-making at various phases of the illness.
精神分裂症的异质性以及经典亚型无法可靠地预测治疗反应,导致了两种截然不同的假设。第一种假设是,所有精神分裂症患者的治疗方法基本相同。第二种假设是,精神分裂症患者的治疗需求只能基于临床“直觉”或治疗师的偏见,因为缺乏做出治疗决策的有意义标准。这两种假设都倾向于阻碍精心且经过批判性推理的治疗计划。本报告认为,当前的知识允许制定一些亚型,这些亚型有助于合理选择个体化的治疗方法。它提出了一些这样的亚型,并探讨了它们在疾病不同阶段治疗决策中的应用。