Cork R C, Vaughan R W, Bentley J B
Anesthesiology. 1981 Apr;54(4):310-3. doi: 10.1097/00000542-198104000-00010.
Specific postoperative outcomes were assessed in 67 morbidly obese subjects who received general anesthesia for gastric stapling. Each patient was randomly assigned to receive N2O:O2 combined with fentanyl (n = 20), enflurane (n = 24), or halothane (n = 23). Time from last skin stitch until the patient opened eyes on command was significantly less for the fentanyl group (3.0 +/- 0.7 min) than for the enflurane group (13.2 +/- 1.9 min) or the halothane group (17.4 +/- 2.9 min) with P less than 0.05. However, no significant differences in time from last skin stitch to extubation were noted among the fentanyl (16.2 +/- 7.4 min), enflurane (15.2 +/- 1.6 min), and halothane (21.6 +/- 5.8 min) groups (P greater than 0.05). Recovery room (RR) admission temperatures were similar for the three groups: fentanyl, 36.1 +/- 0.1 degrees C; enflurane, 35.7 +/- 0.2 degrees C; and halothane, 36.0 +/- 0.1 degrees C (P greater than 0.05). Total RR time was not significantly different: fentanyl, 108 +/- 6 min, enflurane, 118 +/- 4 min; and halothane, 112 +/- 10 min (P greater than 0.05). In addition, no difference in RR and 24-hour postoperative narcotic (meperidine) requirements was demonstrated among the anesthetic groups. These data suggest that increased lipid solubility of volatile anesthetics (halothane or enflurane) produces neither delayed awakening nor prolonged recovery time in morbidly obese subjects. Considering the early (24 hour) postoperative outcomes studied, there is little to commend one general anesthetic technique over another in the obese subset of the population.
对67例接受胃吻合术全身麻醉的病态肥胖受试者的特定术后结果进行了评估。将每位患者随机分配接受笑气:氧气联合芬太尼(n = 20)、恩氟烷(n = 24)或氟烷(n = 23)。芬太尼组从最后一针皮肤缝合到患者按指令睁眼的时间(3.0±0.7分钟)明显短于恩氟烷组(13.2±1.9分钟)或氟烷组(17.4±2.9分钟),P值小于0.05。然而,芬太尼组(16.2±7.4分钟)、恩氟烷组(15.2±1.6分钟)和氟烷组(21.6±5.8分钟)从最后一针皮肤缝合到拔管的时间无显著差异(P值大于0.05)。三组患者进入恢复室(RR)时的体温相似:芬太尼组为36.1±0.1℃;恩氟烷组为35.7±0.2℃;氟烷组为36.0±0.1℃(P值大于0.05)。总RR时间无显著差异:芬太尼组为108±6分钟,恩氟烷组为118±4分钟;氟烷组为112±10分钟(P值大于0.05)。此外,各麻醉组之间在RR及术后24小时麻醉剂(哌替啶)需求量方面无差异。这些数据表明,挥发性麻醉剂(氟烷或恩氟烷)脂溶性增加在病态肥胖受试者中既不会导致苏醒延迟,也不会延长恢复时间。考虑到所研究的术后早期(24小时)结果,在肥胖人群中,一种全身麻醉技术并不比另一种更具优势。