Skinner H A
Br J Psychiatry. 1981 Apr;138:312-20. doi: 10.1192/bjp.138.4.312.
This study examined characteristics of 296 alcohol and/or drug abuse clients assigned to either (1) in-patient programmes, (2) out-patient programmers, or (3) a lower cost primary care alternative. Multivariate analysis indicated that clients admitted for in-patient care reported greater alcohol consumption and associated problems, fewer community supports and more severe symptoms such as depression and anxiety. They tended to be more frank about their problems while defence mechanisms were more apparent in clients admitted to out-patient and primary care programmers. In general, out-patients ahd more favourable prognostic indicators, such as higher social stability and lower level of alcoholic involvement. The differences among treatment programmers were along quantitative dimensions of problem severity. In particular, the alcohol dependence syndrome was a major discriminating dimension.
本研究调查了296名酒精和/或药物滥用患者的特征,这些患者被分配到以下三种治疗方案之一:(1)住院治疗项目,(2)门诊治疗项目,或(3)低成本的初级保健替代方案。多变量分析表明,接受住院治疗的患者报告饮酒量更大且伴有相关问题,社区支持更少,抑郁和焦虑等症状更严重。他们往往对自己的问题更坦率,而防御机制在门诊和初级保健项目的患者中更为明显。总体而言,门诊患者有更有利的预后指标,如更高的社会稳定性和更低的酒精依赖程度。不同治疗项目之间的差异体现在问题严重程度的数量维度上。特别是,酒精依赖综合征是一个主要的区分维度。