Pompe-Kirn V, Ravnihar B, Ferligoj A
Neoplasma. 1981;28(3):363-9.
The authors present the problem of validity of numerator and pertinence of denominator for small geographical areas on sample of average annual crude incidence rates of stomach cancer in Slovenia during the period 1968--1974. At census in 1971 this country counted 1 727 137 of population. According to the residence of the patients the rates have been calculated for 60 municipalities, and besides for 29 so called "epidemiological regions", defined by their geographical and ethnic characteristics. Although in both instances great differences in incidence rates have been found, only a few areal units exhibited a significantly lower or higher rate from the national average. Specially areas with small population base "disappeared" in the average, although the value of the rate for them was rather low or high. A formula is presented by which at given rate for total country it is possible to determine the minimal size of population which still could provide estimation of statistically significant lower rate. Thus, for areas with small population a period of observation through many years is required in order to obtain the necessary minimal population base. The question is pointed out, whether this approach is reasonable as to the epidemiological interest, considering that some factors related to cancer may change during the long period of time. On the other hand, when merging small areas into larger ones, attention must be paid that these are not too heterogeneous as to their cancer incidence rate, geographical, ethnic, socio-economic and life-style features.
作者提出了斯洛文尼亚1968 - 1974年期间胃癌年均粗发病率样本中,小地理区域分子有效性和分母相关性的问题。1971年人口普查时,该国人口为1727137人。根据患者居住地,计算了60个市的发病率,此外还计算了29个根据地理和民族特征定义的所谓“流行病学区域”的发病率。尽管在这两种情况下都发现发病率存在很大差异,但只有少数区域单位的发病率显著低于或高于全国平均水平。特别是人口基数小的地区在平均值中“消失”了,尽管它们的发病率值相当低或高。文中给出了一个公式,根据全国给定的发病率,可以确定仍能提供具有统计学意义的较低发病率估计的最小人口规模。因此,对于人口少的地区,需要多年的观察期才能获得必要的最小人口基数。考虑到一些与癌症相关的因素可能在很长一段时间内发生变化,从流行病学角度来看,这种方法是否合理引发了质疑。另一方面,在将小区域合并为大区域时,必须注意这些区域在癌症发病率、地理、民族、社会经济和生活方式特征方面不能过于异质。