Mitchell J H, Dunn J P
J Occup Med. 1978 Dec;20(12):797-800.
Health maintenance organizations report lower hospitalization and surgical experience than fee-for-service practice. If this is true, then sickness absence should be less. This pilot study compared morbidity experience of 247 pairs of Mountain Bell Telephone Company employees--HMO-enrolled employees matched with employees covered only by Blue Cross/Blue Shield. The study period extended before and after enrollment of the HMO subjects. Rates for the HMO group for hospitalization and surgery decreased after enrollment, whereas rates for the Blue Cross/Blue Shield group increased. The absence disability rate for the HMO group remained constant but increased for the BC/BS group. Differences in absenteeism may exist due to the type of medical insurance. The potential impact of such a difference upon absence costs is considerable.
健康维护组织报告称,其住院和手术情况比按服务收费的医疗模式要少。如果这是真的,那么病假缺勤情况应该也较少。这项试点研究比较了247对山铃电话公司员工的发病情况——加入健康维护组织的员工与仅由蓝十字/蓝盾保险覆盖的员工相匹配。研究期涵盖了健康维护组织参保对象参保前后的时间段。参保后,健康维护组织组的住院率和手术率下降,而蓝十字/蓝盾组的相应比率上升。健康维护组织组的缺勤残疾率保持不变,但蓝十字/蓝盾组有所上升。由于医疗保险类型的不同,缺勤情况可能存在差异。这种差异对缺勤成本的潜在影响相当大。